Chapter 2 :The GREEKS
now will now turn to look at the life and thought of Socrates. It was he who developed the philosophical process of thought
and who focused on matters of great concern to humans. He was concerned with the question: How do I live a Good
Life? He was concerned with
questions of knowledge, truth, beauty and Goodness.
He was executed for his beliefs and virtues. An interesting story and a life that produced such a great
impact on the world that it is true to say that what Socrates did changed
the world. If Socrates had
not lived as he did you and I would not be as we are today.
In fact we probably would not exist at all.
Illustrated website with Socrates Lifeline:
If you want to look at at very good website with photographs of Athens in the time of Socrates, with photos of what it looks like today and material on Socrates, events in nearly every year of his life with photographs and illustrations and photos of artifacts from the time period, go to this PBS site and click on the material that is associated with Socrates. The site has audio, video, flash graphics and photos and a lot of printed material.
So that we can better understand how Philosophy began in the West it would be valuable to learn something of the life and times of Socrates. Thus the significance of what he did, what he invented and what he left behind will be better appreciated.
An Excellent site listing other sites is this one:
Catholic Encyclopedia Entry for Socrates:
Xenophon- Memoribilia and the Symposium from whom we learn of the every day details and colorful aspects of Socrates life, his wife and children. He presents Socrates as a popular ethical teacher and a promoter of common sense morality who strove to make others good men and citizens.
Aristophanes- whose play,Clouds, used the name of Socrates in a comedy. He made fun of his friend in a farce. He presented a burlesque figure of Socrates.
Aristotle- who tells us that Socrates never taught about anything relating to the idea of the eternal forms which was later developed by Plato.
Plato- who gives us a very detailed description of the Socratic method of questioning, the dialectic process of Philosophy and Socrates concern for virtue and truth.
Key events in Socrates
Anaxagoras arrives in Athens-invited to set up a "school"
Anaxagoras was the thinker who taught that the universe was made up of Mind and Matter. Mind or NOUS set it all in motion in the beginning and has very little to do with it afterwards. The sun was a ball of fire and not a god and the moon was a rock reflecting light and not a goddess. Athens invited him to town and set him up so that he would teach others about his ideas. He had considerable reputation. The Athenians enjoyed and valued the life of the mind. After it became apparent that Anaxagoras was not supportive of Athenian traditions he was charged with being an atheist, harmful to Athens and he escaped before he could be punished (executed). See below 450BC
Xerxes , king of Persia, defeated at Plataea
This event enabled the Greeks and the Athenians , in particular, to focus more on their cultural advancement.
drama the Persians performed at Pericles request
In this play the rule of reason over violence is promoted.
is born of Antiochid tribe, ward of Alopece
His father was a successful stone cutter and his mother a mid-wife.
Socrates spent most of his life speaking with his fellow Athenians and anyone else who wished to speak with him. He spoke about matters of great importance to him, he sought after answers to important questions. He was not a Sophist as he never charged anyone for any lessons concerning anything. He did not claim to know the answers. He did not attempt to win contests with prizes. He was seriously interested in learning about truth, beauty, goodness and virtue. He entered the public spaces of Athens each day to speak with and question his fellows and pursue after wisdom to know the difference between what he knew and what he did not know.
454. Aeschylus ‘ Orestes trilogy performed
450. Anaxagoras leaves Athens, fearing punishment, Archelaus
enjoys a "30 years peace" with Sparta
Free of fear of the arch rival , Athens could devote more time and resources to its own development.
consults the Oracle on Delphos-
Chaerephon is a well-to-do Athenian who journeys to the Oracle of Apollo at Delphi in order to ask a question. The temples were places that the Greeks could ask for assistance. From some surviving descriptions of events at the temples it appears that at many temples young girls would serve as vehicles for the transmission of the words of the divinities. Now the expressions of the oracles were somewhat ambiguous. There was a reason for this. Today something is called “oracular” and by that is meant: an oral answer that has the tone of authority and may be somewhat obscure or ambiguous. The petitioner would call upon the priest of the temple for assistance(for a fee) . The question would be sent to the deity. The temple virgins might enter into a trance (some say induced epileptic fit) and they would make strange sounds while appearing possessed by the deity. The petitioner would ask assistance from the priest who would interpret what the deity was saying through the utterances of the virgins. Two examples of such oracular sayings and their ambiguous nature.
1. King of Lydia went to Dephos and asked the god”Should I go to war with Cyrus , king of persi?” The oracle responded with “If Croesus goes to war with Cyrus he shall bring down a mighty kingdom.” Well with that the king returned to his kingdom and took his army and invaded Persia. King Cyrus sent his army after them and defeated the Lydians. King Croesus escaped. He returned to Delphos to express his anger at the god for misleading him. The priest of the temple pointed out that the god did not mislead but spoke the truth. King Croesus did bring down a mighty kingdom. His own!
2. Chaerephon goes to Delphos and asks “Who is the wisest?” He is told: "There is no one wiser than Socrates". He returns to Athens with the answer and seeks Socrates. He informs Socrates of the answer of the god. Socrates thinks ther must be some mistake. He does not believe he is wise at all. He sets out to learn from those who are truly wise. Perhaps, the god meant for Socrates to seek wisdom (Philosophy). As Socrates questions all those who claim to know important matters and those who were reputed to be wise , he finds that they do not know what they claim to know. While Socrates who claims to know nothing appears to be quite wise in admitting that he does not know. Socrates thinks that perhaps the god has used Socrates to teach humans a lesson: that the highest wisdom they can achieve is to admit their ignorance.
Meanwhile, there were those in Athens who thought themselves to be quite wise. There were the Sophists who would win debates and public speaking events and were thought to be wise. If any of these reported wise men were to go to the Temple at Delphos to complain about the expression of the god the priest of the temple could calm them by pointing out that the god did NOT say that Socrates was the wisest of all, no, only that there was no one wiser than Socrates. Surely these wise and powerful and wealthy individuals were just as wise as Socrates, the god did not want to list them all. That was all.
Socrates seeks after the wise to learn what their wisdom is and how one could acquire it. He questions those who claim to have knowledge. In the ION Socrates is questioning someone who has won a prize for public speaking (recitation and who thinks that because he has memorized some lines on a subject that he really understands what it is all about. Socrates questions show that he doesn't.
432. Peloponesian war breaks out again
431. Pericles Funeral oration given in Thucydides History
of Potidaea- Socrates and Alcibiades participate
Socrates left the town limits of Athens only three times in his entire life. All three times was as a soldier to defend Athens! Socrates acts heroically. Alcibiades is a handsome young man and great warrior, a soldier of fortune, who enjoys himself a great deal. You may read about this at the end of the SYMPOSIUM . (You will be required to read the SYMPOSIUM later in another section.) Text is available at http://www.eserver.org/philosophy/plato/symposium.txt
424. Socrates serves as a "hoplite" at Delium .
423. Aristophanes play Clouds, was first produced in the drama festival in Athens—the City Dionysia—in 423 BC, where it placed third. In this play, the author, a friend of Socrates, uses his name in a comedy that criticizes the Sophists. Many who see the play do not realize that the character named “Socrates” in the play did not depict the actual thinking of Socrates. It was burlesque and farce; an exaggerated comic depiction.
On Satire in Aristophanes's Clouds, a lecture by Ian Johnston.
The text and some information about the play Clouds,
422. Socrates serves as a hoplite at the battle of Amphipolis
421. Nominal peace of Nicias which lasts for 2 to 3 years
Agathon wins first drama prize and feast is held afterwards
READ about this in the dialogue SYMPOSIUM
is disgraced in a "religious scandal". He and his friends are
thought to have mutilated the statues in Athens and that of the god ,
Alcibiades flees Athens and works for the Spartans! He is a soldier of fortune working for the arch enemy. He seduces the wife of the king of Sparta while he was away. Alcibiades fled to Persia where he became a leader in their army.
Euripedes play the Trojan Woman is performed in which the very idea of warfare is criticized by showing the price paid for it by innocent beings.
enters into warfare in Sicily against Syracuse
Athens- "Oligarchy of the 400" takes control
Aristophanes play Lysistrata
is performed, in which the comedian makes fun of war.
is recalled to Athens only to leave shortly thereafter in disgrace again
406. Trial of the ten Athenian generals en bloc for negligence
at the battle of Arginisai
Socrates is head of the panel of Judges and is sole dissenter. The mob wanted to have a trial for ten generals all at the same time and then to execute them all for their crimes against their men, the enemy and Athens. Socrates is chief judge of the court on that day and he refuses the demands of the mob because it was against Athenian Law to put all ten on trial at once, lest the guilt of many cover over the innocence of even one of the others. Socrates grants separate trials
Sophocles and Euripedes die
Socrates in Athens speaking with Plato. (Painting by Raphael. )
Athens capitulates to Sparta
The brutal Spartan commander, Lysander, appoints a Commission of Thirty to rule over Athens. They become the Terror, the "Tyranny of the Thirty". The tyrant would order Athenians arrested and then execute them or exile them and take their property. If there were those who criticized the Thirty who had money, prestige or power, the Thirty would order them to take part in these seizures or face the wrath of the Thirty. Socrates knew the Thirty. Several had listened to Socrates in discussions as they were growing up. Socrates was critical of their actions and expressed those criticisms. The Thirty wished to silence his criticisms. On one occasion Socrates is ordered to go with Meletus and arrest Leon of Salamis. Socrates dissents in the arrest of Leon of Salamis by the order of Critias and the Thirty. Meletus is in the group that carries out the arrest order. If Socrates had gone along with the scheme, he would have “blood on his hands” after being involved with the work of the Thirty and thus, they thought he would be silent. Socrates refused to cooperate with their nefarious schemes and evil deeds. They wished to silence him and so they issued an edict that no one could teach public speaking. Thus, they thought they would silence Socrates from speaking in public. When Socrates heard of this edict, even that it was intended to silence him, he thought that there must be something wrong with the edict for it would appear to ban anyone from speaking in the presence of another human being, because it is through observing others speak that we learn. He refused to obey what was a defective decree. It appears the Thirty were going to take action against Socrates when a revolution took place.
403. Order is restored by a group that institutes a Democracy
Meletus and Lycon lead the party and movement.
Amnesty is declared. The laws are revised and codified.
Meletus prosecutes the poet Andocides for "impiety" –Anytus defends him.
accuses Socrates of "impiety" and "corrupting the
Socrates looks for the basis of morality in reasoning and not in the simple repetition of the examples set out in the tales of the gods and goddesses. READ an example of this in the EUTHYPHRO at http://www.eserver.org/philosophy/plato/euthyphro.txt
Socrates appears for trial and makes his defense, his Apology
READ Plato's account of Socrates' defense in the APOLOGY
is found guilty, sentenced to die,
In prison he is invited to flee and live in exile but refuses to do so: the CRITO
executed by drinking hemlock.
He offers arguments for the existence and immortality of the soul in the last hours of his life. We shall read about this in a later lecture when we will read the PHAEDO
Additional interesting material will be found at these sites:
A site on Plato and Socrates, his life, thought, method and more!
What Socrates taught. An excellent site by Sanderson Beck
Proceed to the next section by clicking here> next section.
© Copyright Philip A. Pecorino 2000. All Rights reserved.
Web Surfer's Caveat: These are class notes, intended to comment on readings and amplify class discussion. They should be read as such. They are not intended for publication or general distribution.
|Return to: Table of Contents for the Online Textbook|