Chapter 2 :The GREEKS
Death of Socrates and Plato’s Theory of the Ideal Forms
describes the death of Socrates in the dialogue, the PHAEDO. In that
dialogue Plato becomes the first human to set into written form an attempt
to prove that human beings have souls which are spiritual and immortal. Many cultures have such a belief. It can be found all around the world. However, the Greeks were the first to attempt to offer a
proof for its existence and a proof based upon reasoning. In order to
understand the PHAEDO and its arguments one must first be aware of
Plato’s Theory of the Forms. This
is needed for Plato makes use of them in attempting to prove that the soul
exists and that it survives the death of the body.
the PHAEDO Plato uses the Theory of the Forms.
Aristotle made it clear that Socrates did not use that theory, it
was developed later by Plato. So
what is most likely is that Plato probably began the dialogue right after
the death of Socrates. He
must have taken notes. He was
not present at the death; he was ill.
He probably recorded what others told him occurred and then years
later returned to the notes and finished the dialogue.
So the PHAEDO is a mix of what Socrates actually said and words
Plato placed into the mouth of Socrates to complete the arguments and
offer stronger ones consistent with Plato’s views.
It is likely a Dialogue from Plato’s middle period of
creativity.(see mini-lecture on Plato’s Dialogues)
The dialogue contains four different arguments to prove the
existence of the soul. Socrates
states at the conclusion of the first that it is sufficient.
The other three were probably added later by Plato and utilize
references to Plato’s theory of the forms.
The THEORY of the FORMS
For many years I presented this theory in class
utilizing a series of questions and practical demonstrations. In this medium we shall attempt to get as close as possible
We start off with a simple question:
What is this a picture of ? >>>>>>>>.
You probably answered that it is a chair. And you are correct!
Now answer this question:
is a chair?
Proceed to the next section to continue the presentation and discussion!
© Copyright Philip A. Pecorino 2000. All Rights reserved.
Web Surfer's Caveat: These are class notes, intended to comment on readings and amplify class discussion. They should be read as such. They are not intended for publication or general distribution.
|Return to: Table of Contents for the Online Textbook|