Hardness of Minerals

BACKGROUND

Though a number of sophisticated tools for mineral identification exist, basic, simple tests, which reveal some aspect of the physical properties of a mineral, are often sufficient to identify a mineral. These tests include hardness, specific gravity, fracture/cleavage, luster, streak, and an analysis of the crystal habit (the common shapes a particular mineral crystallizes in).  The hardness test can be performed with everyday materials and requires no special equipment. However, a special set of "pencils" with the hardness minerals mounted as points is available from several gemology supply manufacturers. For cut stones, plates of the test mineral, including up to synthetic corundum, are available as well.

Hardness is the resistance of a substance to being scratched by another material. A scratch is a permanent line or groove cut into the surface of the material being tested and caution should be taken not to damage a valuable gem.  The test should be made in an inconspicuous place such as the girdle of a cut stone.  Don't attempt to test gems until you have acquired a great amount of practical experience testing common minerals.  Rough gem material is more applicable for testing than cut stones, which could potentially receive serious damage by overzealous testing.

 One important property of a gem is that it must be hard enough to resist everyday wear and tear. Harder gems take a better polish and thus appear more lustrous. If a gem is softer than 7 on Moh's Scale, it will lose its luster as dust from the air (dust contains silica, hardness 7) slowly makes minute scratches on the gem's surface.
 
 

While a number of hardness scales exist, the most commonly used in geology and gemology is the Moh's scale; Moh's assigned relative numerical  values to pure minerals as follows:
 
 
 

MINERAL HARDNESS
Talc (talcum power is softer than skin)  1
Gypsum (used in plaster of paris) 2
Calcite 3
Fluorite 4
Apatite 5
Orthoclase (feldspar) 6
Quartz 7
Topaz 8
Corundum (sapphire & ruby) 9
Diamond (hardest natural substance) 10

Friedrich Moh, a German mineralogist, proposed his scale in 1822. Because it uses universally available common minerals, Moh's scale became well accepted.  It is only a relative scale since the minerals are not equally times harder than each other.  For example, the difference between diamond's hardness and that of corundum is greater than the difference in hardness between all other minerals on the scale (1 talc-9 corundum)!

All minerals and natural substances have a value somewhere between 1 and 10.  A useful mnemonic, a device for remembering the mineral names in the correct sequence, 1 - 10, is the sentence "The Good Cat Finds An Old Quilt To Curl Down."

Several common objects have a hardness identical (or very closely matching) those on the scale and are available for use just about everywhere. These include:
 
 
 

COMMON TEST SUBSTANCES RELATIVE HARDNESS
Fingernail 2
Copper penny 3
Steel pocket knifeblade 5
Glass plate (window glass) 5.5
Hardened steel file/porcelain tile 6.5
Quartz 7

 

Most minerals have a hardness between 2 and 7, using the common materials to determine the hardness usually works . In practice, use the softest test object on the sample first.  If it is harder, it will scratch the substance leaving a permanent mark that will not wipe away; items of equal hardness should scratch each other. Results are best when using relatively pure samples.  Impurities could give a false reading; so inspect the sample and the tested object with a magnifier. 


SAFETY PRECAUTIONS

The test objects such as glass, pocketknives, and quartz specimens can be very sharp and students need to exercise caution in doing these tests so as not to cut themselves. Place the specimen on a stable work surface, and then try to make a small scratch on it with the testing implement.  Do not move the test object towards yourself and point it away from others so that if particles fly off no one is hit! 

 
 

 The following minerals occur in granite.  Which mineral in granite is most resistant to abrasion (scratching)?
 

QUARTZ
Fingernail
2
Penny
2
Knife
5
Glass
5.5
File
6.5
Scratches object
Is scratched by object
BIOTITE
Fingernail
2
Penny
2
Knife
5
Glass
5.5
File
6.5
Scratches object
Is scratched by object
PINK ORTHOCLASE FELDSPAR
Fingernail
2
Penny
2
Knife
5
Glass
5.5
File
6.5
Scratches object
Is scratched by object